Here is how I can prove that it is a universal principle to have a system where Government redistribution of wealth so every American has exactly the same amount of wealth….works…..let me explain why……
1) Suppose you have a pond, and then it rains heavily on one part of the pond. The rainwater would be redistributed equally across the surface of the entire pond. The depth of all parts of the pond would raise by exactly the same amount, whether or not rainwater fell on any part of the pond. And it still rains….because the rain pours on the pond not to enrich just where that cloud is situated, but for the greater good of the entire pond.
Scientifically, if ponds of water behaved like American society, there would be no ponds of water. Because all the rain clouds would have no incentive to exist unless each area of the pond did not connect to any other part of the pond.
As a society, we are all like a pond and we share the earth and wealth and food and solar energy…and this proves my point, we’d be happiest if like that pond, we shared each money cloud in common….
Does this anlogy work for most of you?
Now, to an extent we are like the pond. You give an employee wealth and he consumes goods and services, which helps businesses grow.
You give an employer wealth, and he may hire another worker, enriching that worker….
so why not expedite the redistribution process by just having the Govt do it
As for people, we have a system where people receive tattoos for hard work….just like ponds have ripples to show where rain fell……
Now those who are not working hard would have the least tattoos and people would be disgusted with them for not pulling their fair share…while they enjoy the same amenities for being human
Talk about a dumb example! The pond does nothing to create the water it holds. The pond doesn’t have human nature.
The government doesn’t create wealth, in fact the bureaucrats skim the cream off the top, gaining greater benefits & security than the private sector.
160 MILLION people were killed by that ideology last century and you want to try it again?
References :
How about you do some sharing?
References :
um……we’re talking people……not ponds.
….your "analogy" doesn’t even work in the realm of single-cell organisms let alone sentient beings like humans….
…and as for allowing the "government" to take charge…understand that for every 6 inches of rain would have to fall in order for the "government" to provide an inch of rainfall to the "pond."
References :
do you have a successful working model we can look too?
References :
The problem is that the human brain is much more complex than a pond. Not even Karl Marx could grasp all the dimensions of how the human brain works in his analogy of ants being an utopian society. The point is that our brain has not evolved to be an utopian society, currently under our present physical conditions an utopia will never work. Sorry we are not that evolved yet. We haven’t passed the tribalism our brains are wired with.
References :
umm so….You are using science to argue communism??
Typical liberal…
References :
I keep hearing about this redistribution of wealth and I haven’t seen any of it yet!!
Oh no, the liberal in me is coming out! I want mine, give me mine!! I want it NOW!!!!!
References :
You can look to Cuba and North Korea for confirmation that this will work.
References :
Talk about a dumb example! The pond does nothing to create the water it holds. The pond doesn’t have human nature.
The government doesn’t create wealth, in fact the bureaucrats skim the cream off the top, gaining greater benefits & security than the private sector.
References :